Soap and Glory Clean on Me Creamy Clarifying Shower Gel: My First Fancy Body Wash

When it comes to bath and body stuff, and even my hair for that matter, I like to keep it frugal so I can splurge on makeup from time to time.  But I got the mini Soap and Glory Righteous body butter around the holidays last year and fell in love with the scent.  In my mind I figured if I got the shower gel in the same scent I would "lock in" the fragrance to my skin and enjoy the scent even longer, thus my purchase of Clean On Me Creamy Clarifying Shower Gel.  I've never bought a body wash over 5 bucks so I expected this to be awesome.  But was it?